CO129-114 - MacDonnell - 1866 [7-8] — Page 256

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

252

b.

Therefore to substitute merely two Companies of such Troops for a full wing of a European Regiment appear to me insufficient.

Nor do I believe that its adequacy is at all made out by Lord Hartington's argument that the reduction of the European Garrison at Warlington ought to lead to a corresponding reduction of its duties.

The latter (except perhaps as to mere Regimental guards), and I cannot conceive how a small body of ... can better put down an insurrection than a large force any more than I can understand how they can more effectually garrison and supply the guards for thirteen or fourteen posts where guards do have now to be mounted and where they always must be mounted.

1. Lord Hartington remarks that an improved organization of the Colonial Police may render the employment of a large native force unnecessary. I think it right to say that, whilst admitting every improvement in the machinery of the Executive Government and an additional guarantee for security of life and property, the improvement of the local Police to such a degree as to dispense with Military protection in those cases where Military protection is specially required and specially appropriate, is a contingency yet too distant to affect the argument.

E. Altogether looking to the value of the Military Station here, the central position of Hongkong in the China Command as compared with Singapore, and the magnitude of the ...

8.

Edit History

2026-05-19 10:42:28 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
252 b. Therefore to substitute merely two Companies of such Troops for a full wing of a European Regiment appear to me insufficient. Nor do I believe that its adequacy is at all made out by Lord Hartington's argument that the reduction of the European Garrison at Warlington ought to lead to a corresponding reduction of its duties. The latter (except perhaps as to mere Regimental guards), and I cannot conceive how a small body of ... can better put down an insurrection than a large force any more than I can understand how they can more effectually garrison and supply the guards for thirteen or fourteen posts where guards do have now to be mounted and where they always must be mounted. 1. Lord Hartington remarks that an improved organization of the Colonial Police may render the employment of a large native force unnecessary. I think it right to say that, whilst admitting every improvement in the machinery of the Executive Government and an additional guarantee for security of life and property, the improvement of the local Police to such a degree as to dispense with Military protection in those cases where Military protection is specially required and specially appropriate, is a contingency yet too distant to affect the argument. E. Altogether looking to the value of the Military Station here, the central position of Hongkong in the China Command as compared with Singapore, and the magnitude of the ... 8.
Baseline (Original)
Ho 252 b. Sherefore to sublitute merely two Companies of such Troops for a fuel wing of a European Regiment appear to me insufficient. adequacy is Warlington's nor do I believe that its I at all made out by Lord.) ) argument the that the reduction of The European Ganisor at Wargting ought to corresponding reduction of its duties". lead ti a The lattu unfortimality (except perhaps runain unaltered as to more Regimental guards), and I cannot conceive how a small body of www can better fint down an insurrection than a large force any understand how they more caw MOVE than I can effectually fanteen supply the guards for shirteen or posts where do have now to be mounted guards and where they always must be mounted. 1. Ford Marlington Hartington remarts haven that an improved organization of the Colonial Police may rendu employment of a large I native force unnecessary. I chime it right to say that, whilst admitting every smpromet in the maching of the Executive Ga mument Coention an additional guarantee for security of I to be life and property, the improvement of the local Police to such a degree as to dispense as with Military protection in those cases where Military protection is specially required and specially appropriate, is a contingency get too distant to affect the argument. E. Altogether loosing to the value of the Military Stover here, the central position of Hongkong in the China Command as compared with Singapore, and the magnitude of the 8.
2026-05-19 10:42:28 · Baseline
View content

Ho

252

b.

Sherefore to sublitute merely two Companies of such Troops for a fuel wing of a European Regiment appear to me

insufficient.

adequacy is Warlington's

nor do I believe that its I

at all made out by Lord.) ) argument the

that the reduction of

The European Ganisor at Wargting ought to corresponding reduction of its duties".

lead ti a

The lattu unfortimality

(except perhaps

runain unaltered

as to more Regimental guards), and I cannot conceive how a small body

of

www

can

better fint down an insurrection

than a large force any understand how they

more

caw MOVE

than I can

effectually fanteen

supply the guards for shirteen or

posts

where

do have now to be mounted

guards

and where they always must be mounted.

1.

Ford Marlington

Hartington remarts haven

that an improved organization of the Colonial

Police may rendu employment of a large

I native force unnecessary. I chime it right to say that, whilst admitting every smpromet in the maching of the Executive Ga mument

Coention an additional guarantee for security of

I

to be

life and property, the improvement of the local Police to such a degree as to dispense

as

with Military protection in those cases where Military protection is specially required and specially appropriate, is a contingency get too distant to affect the argument. E. Altogether loosing to the value of the Military Stover here, the central position of Hongkong in the China Command as compared with Singapore, and the magnitude of the

8.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.